|
|
(Larger Image)
|
Bhagavad-Gita As It Is
by A. C. Bhaktivedanta
Product Group: Book
Publisher: Bhaktivedanta Book Trust (1997-03)
ISBN: 089213285X
EAN: 9780892132850
Dewy Decimal #: 294
Hardcover: 1047 pages
Edition: Deluxe
SKU: 08070241
Condition: Very Good Very Good
Comments: Hardback First Printing 1983 and Printing in West Germany. In very good condition with no markings. Dust jacket in very good condition with minor shelf wear. Tanning of edges. Tight binding and clear crisp text. Very nice book.
|
Editorial Reviews
|
Product Description
The Bhagavad-Gita is the main source-book on yoga and a concise summary of India's Vedic wisdom. Yet remarkably, the setting for this best-known classic of spiritual literature is an ancient Indian battlefield. At the last moment before entering battle, the great warrior Arjuna begins to wonder about the real meaning of his life. Why should he fight against his friends and relatives? Why does he exist? Where is he going after death? In the Bhagavad-Gita, Lord Krsna, Arjuna's friend and spiritual master, brings His disciple from perplexity to spiritual enlightenment. In the course of doing so, Krsna concisely but definitively explains transcendental knowledge; karma-yoga, jnana-yoga, dhyana-yoga, and bhakti-yoga; knowledge of the Absolute; devotional service; the three modes of material nature; the divine and demoniac natures; and much more. Bhagavad-Gita As It Is is the largest-selling, most widely used edition of the Gita in the world.
|
Customer Reviews
|
From my review of "The Essence of the Bhagavad-Gita"
Rating  (5)
Date: 2007-09-25
2 out of 4 customers found this reveiw helpful
An exerpt for the Vaishnava section on Wikipedia website:
"While many schools like Smartism and Advaitism encourage interpretation of scriptures philosophically and metaphorically and not too literally, (Gaudiya)Vaishnavism stresses the literal meaning (mukhya vitti) as primary and indirect meaning (gaua vitti) as secondary: sâkhâd upadesas tu shrutih - "The instructions of the shruti-shâstra should be accepted literally, without fanciful or allegorical interpretations." Jiva Goswami, Krishna Sandarbha 29.26-27" (This is from a Hare Krishna/I.S.K.O.N/Gaudiya sampradayam scripture)
This is my review of the book "The Essence of the Bhagavad Gita: Explained by Paramhansa Yogananda". And, it is very much related to this particular translation of the Bhagavad-gita and the group that uses it. Please read the following:
"I must say this first,I have been studying the Vedic scriptures since about 96',and, I am sorry to say,I was a Hare Krishna devotee for about four years from 02' to 06'. I was one of the Pujaris or Ceremonial priest in the now defunct Venice Radha-Govinda temple in Venice, Ca. I learned alot of the basic principles of the Vedic religion from them. Outside the elementary principles, much of what they teach is tinged with thier particular sect/cult flavor or doctrine. I.S.K.O.N/Gaudiya math or the Hare Krishnas believe and see only a totally historical, surface understanding of the Bhagavad-gita, other vedic scriptures and stories. They critizes,condemn and keep down with fanatical furvor,as I have experienced with them...the notion of a deeper,Intuitive, Spiritual, Philosophical, Esoteric truth to the Vedic scriptures and stories,that are outside thier cult. The whole time I was with them, I felt like I was being intuitively,soulfully,esoterically and philosophically strangled. They believed with the extremism and fanatism of Southern Baptists in the total surface-value,exoteric understanding of the Vedas. I was always chastized and critized for my pro-esoteric/intuitive understanding of the Vedas and reading books on the vedic scriptures or vedic commentaries not published by ISKON. Before coming to I.S.K.O.N or Gaudiya math, I always Knew,intuitively and through my own many Spiritual experiences through valid,vedically-backed meditations and excerises as instucted in the Vedas,upanishads,Yoga-sutras and Tantras, that there was and has always been and always be...a deeper, esoteric, hidden meaning and understanding to the Bible,Gnostic texts, the greek myths, alchemical allegories and symbolism, to the Homeric epics and...to the Vedas,the bhagavad-gita and Puranas. And, come to find out, from Swami Kriyananda,Swami Yogananda, Swami Shivananda, and many, many,other hindu holy men....this is the proper "Brahminical" or Priest/Yogi Caste understanding of the Revealed scriptures, the truely Philosophical. This is also confirmed in some verses from the very scriptures that I.S.K.O.N uses. But, they do not truely acknowledge them. Before coming to I.S.K.O.N and Gaudiya math,I use to love the Bhagavad-gita, and I knew that there was a deeper, esoteric truth to it and other Vedic scripture that ONLY a meditator or some one who had direct experience in Linking and Communion between God and the Soul. The Real Brahmin Caste in India Truely understand this, and Actually, the term Brahmana, means "One who KNOWS Brahman" or one who has attain this Linking and Communion with God or Brahman,fully or to a certain extent. This is what Makes a Brahmin...I.S.K.O.N talks about this truth, but, thier understanding of a "Brahmana" is that of the physical caste person performing rituals and even then, they are against them also. Every thing with them is outwardly-driven...in stead of focusing within them. The vedic scriptures say this over and over again,looking to the Paramatma within, they think they are above this principle and I have seen first hand the effects in their orgainization and the people. Their Translation of the Bhagavad-gita, Sri Isopanishad and other Vedic scriptures are the most Blantantly mistranslated editions of these scriptures I have ever came across. Mistranslated and written to suit their particular cult/sect slant, flavor and agenda. I read their particular translation The Bhagavad-Gita 3 times since 02'; every time it was boring, dry,mistranslated to suit their cult beliefs,and it took me approx. 3 months each time to study it...it was a real arduos task to do it each time and, for a time, it has totally turned me off from the Bhagavad-gita...sorry to say. And, it has bothered me that my experiences in the cult I.S.K.O.N/Gaudiya math or the Hare Krishnas has affected so much that it Burnt me on the Bhagavad-gita. Since leaving the temple on Watseka ave., I couldnt even look at other Bhagavad-gitas with out thinking about the extreme mistranslations of the I.S.K.O.N one and the fanaticsm,extremism and philosophical,emotional,verbal and physical intimidation and abuse of this group has done. This has really bothered me. Then one week ago, while I was at a barns and nobles, I accidentally came across this book. And, it has been a breath of freash air. This book proves my original intuitions of the Scripture were correct and gives insight to much, much more. It flys in the face of the fanatical, and in certain verses, the absolutely incorrect translations of this group. This book of Swami Kriyanandas has all but disolved the Southern Baptist/Christian evangelistic-like understanding of the Hare Krishnas for the Vedas. And, it is nice that there are others who agree with the Inner-Intuitive TRUTH of the Scriptures. And that there are others who are Free-Thinkers and above Fananticism. This book of Swami Kriyanandas has brought me back to the Bhagavad-gita....like the prodical Son, coming back to his Father."
By writing this, it is my catharsis from being with these people.
|
|
So deeply empowering
Rating (5)
Date: 2006-02-20
6 out of 9 customers found this reveiw helpful
I've read the Bhagavad-gita by other authors, but this edition of the Bhagavad-gita made it so clear and easy to understand. I especially enjoyed it because it is directly translated from the Sanskrit to English. So you know it's accurate. After reading it, I began to feel a joyous serenity. I highly recommend this book.
|
|
I am not a Hare Krishna
Rating  (1)
Date: 2004-06-20
11 out of 19 customers found this reveiw helpful
The Hare Krishna's did most of the five star reviews. If you read the few reviews that are not posted by Hare Krishna's (most give it one star) you will find that other people who are familiar with the actual Bhagavad Gita hate this version. The commentary is by the spiritual leader of the Hare Krishna movement and as such it is so different from mainstream readings that it is kooky. I can't say enough about what a great spiritual book the Gita is, but not this version. Check out the Bhagavad Gita translated by either Stephen Mitchell or Eknath Easwaran for a more accurate presentation.
|
|
Not actually the Gita--A Cult deception
Rating (1)
Date: 2003-09-28
12 out of 22 customers found this reveiw helpful
Don't be fooled by all the positive reviews (by International Society of Krishna Consciousness devotees), the title "AS IT IS" is added to confuse the fact that this commentary distorts the Gita's meaning out of recognition. Immerse youself in another version that bears the name "The Bhagavad Gita" and you will find most of the key ideas present in this "AS IT IS" version to be quite diffent, focused as it is, on the supreme Godhead as an
actual person rather than a universal presence, focused as this is on a single technique (bhakti/devotion) when the actual Bhagavad Gita teaches many paths. Ridculously, in order to combat the true Gita's words, this commentator resorts to absurdities that only a brain-washed cult member would accept. For example, to disclaim the obvious emphasis the true Gita places on the practice of meditation, Prahupda claims that back then people lived 60,000 years and could sit in meditation for 100's of years at a stretch, but today, since people live such short life spans, the Gita's teaching on meditation is no longer valid. Believe this sort of stuff and he may be able to convince you nirvana lies in a spaceship hiding behind a comet and all you have to do is drink some special Kool-Aid to make it there.
|
|
This is Gods Real Message!
Rating (5)
Date: 2002-09-12
7 out of 12 customers found this reveiw helpful
I have read many editions of Bhagavad-gita before, but in all of them the authors seemed to be eager to veil the direct meaning of the text. This editions were dry, highly speculative, full of logical flaws and actually lifeless. What a pleasant surprise is this edition! It vibrates with life and can easiliy be related to the real desires in every persons heart, which are love and rich and profound relationships. And as this edition plainly and by use of conquering and perfect logic states, this all starts by reestablishing our love and appreciation for the personal center of all that exists, the Supreme Person.
I highly recommend this edition of Bhagavad-gita for everyone, who is searching for juicy and spicy life instead of boring and out-of-touch impersonal speculations of other editions.
|
|
|
|
|